← Back to Deck Comparisons

The Natural Wood Showdown: Cedar vs. Treated Lumber

Before the invention of synthetic composites, there were only two viable ways to build an outdoor wooden structure: chemically pressure-treat soft yellow pine to force it to resist rot, or pay a premium to import naturally rot-resistant Western Red Cedar. While both materials offer the authentic warmth of real wood, their lifespans and maintenance requirements are incredibly different.

Pressure-Treated (ACQ) Pine

The undisputed king of budget builds.

"Treated lumber" refers to standard Southern Yellow Pine that has been sealed in an industrial cylinder and injected with chemicals (typically Alkaline Copper Quaternary) at high pressures. This chemical bath saturates the wood fibers, making them utterly indigestible to termites and highly resistant to fungal rot. It is the cheapest decking material available, universally costing $35 to $55 per square foot completely installed (including the underlying framing structure).

However, the chemical treatment does not prevent the wood from warping. As treated pine bakes in the Iowa sun and absorbs massive amounts of rainfall, the boards frequently cup, twist, and develop severe splinters within the first five years. Walking barefoot on an older treated pine deck is inherently risky.

Western Red Cedar

The luxury natural alternative.

Cedar lumber is imported from the Pacific Northwest. It is naturally infused with wood oils and tannins that organically resist rot and insect infiltration without the need for toxic pressure treatments. Furthermore, cedar is an incredibly dimensionally stable wood—meaning that it lays perfectly flat and rarely warps, cups, or splits, making it incredibly safe for bare feet.

The drawback is price. Cedar must be harvested from old-growth and second-growth forests, making it a premium import commodity in the Midwest. A fully installed cedar deck typically costs between $55 and $75 per square foot, making it 40% to 60% more expensive than treated pine.

The Universal Maintenance Burden

Regardless of whether your wood is chemically treated pine or naturally resilient cedar, both decks will rapidly turn a weathered, silvery-gray if exposed to UV radiation. To maintain the rich brown/red wood aesthetic of either material, the deck must be power washed and re-stained with a penetrating UV-blocking oil every 2 to 3 years.